Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Hana Kabele Gala's avatar

This is a beautiful review and well-deserved high praise for a one the most singular films of the last decade.

Three notes: 1) The acting is so spectacular that it will leave you breathless. Joanna Kulig, who plays Zula, deserves all the accolades. If you want to see a talent about 50 levels above whoever gets the Oscar (say, Meryl Streep, let alone Mikey Madison), this is it.

2) This text says "The performing arts never change.... Love also never changes." But I wonder if the point of the movie is that it actually does change, all the time. It was there, and we know because *we* were there, and now we want it again, but we're different, and the love is different, and we want that new flavor with this person, but we are also missing the old love, and finding the same footing is hard even when you are crazy about the other.

And, also, Zola and Tomasz may be soulmates, but what does that get them? How many in the audience think: "Gosh, I'd leave the free world and return to suffering if it meant being near the one person who is a part of me?" and how many just thought: I don't get it. Is that a good thing? Is loving this hard a sign of unhinged lack of self-control or the most beautiful experience God is offering (a nod to Ida perhaps).

3) It's an excellent review and I can't wait to watch Fatherland. Very happy I discovered American Innocence.

Ready for more?